Influencer marketing: how to find the right creators
Influencer marketing starts with audience fit: how to search, shortlist and vet creators before you spend.

Finding influencers isn’t hard. Finding the right ones is. Follower count is the easiest number to see and the least useful on its own. What matters is who follows them, how engaged those people are, and whether the creator genuinely fits your brand.
This guide shows how to search, shortlist and vet creators before you spend a dollar.
Start with your customer, not the creator
- Who is your ideal customer: age, location, interests, life stage?
- Which accounts do your best customers already follow? Ask them.
- What topics and content types does that audience engage with?
- What would a creator need to believably use your product?
Where to look
- Your own followers and tagged posts: customers who already love you
- Hashtags and locations relevant to your product and area
- Competitors’ tagged posts and partnerships
- Platform tools such as Instagram’s and TikTok’s creator marketplaces
- Creator platforms and agencies for larger campaigns
- Podcasts, newsletters and YouTube channels in your niche
Check fit before reach
- Importance
- How easy to check
Our view, scored out of 5. Ask for audience insights screenshots before booking.
Spot fake or inflated audiences
- Sudden jumps in followers with no viral post to explain them
- Comments that are generic (“Nice!”, emojis only) or from unrelated accounts
- Very high follower count with very low views or likes
- Large share of followers outside your market
- Engagement that doesn’t match the creator’s usual level on sponsored posts
Score your shortlist
- 30,000
- 900
- 45
- 70%
- $800
- Engagement rate
- 3.2%
- Engaged Australians per post
- 662
- Cost per engaged Australian
- $1
Compare creators on cost per engaged person in your market, not cost per follower.
Reach out properly
- Personalise your message: mention specific content you liked
- Explain why your brand fits their audience
- Be clear about what you’re offering: product, fee, or both
- Ask for their media kit and audience insights
- Start with a small test before a long-term deal
How this looks in your industry
Illustrative examples
Closest to you
E-commerce
A baby products brand
The problem: Chose creators by follower count.
What changed: Asked customers which parenting accounts they followed and shortlisted from there.
Result: Creators whose audiences actually bought.
Closest to you
Hospitality
A Brisbane brunch café
The problem: Approached national food influencers.
What changed: Worked with local creators with engaged Brisbane audiences.
Result: Visible weekend queues from people who saw the posts.
Closest to you
Trades
A kitchen renovation company
The problem: Assumed influencers didn’t suit trades.
What changed: Partnered with a local home and renovation creator to document a project.
Result: Enquiries from homeowners planning similar work.
Common mistakes
- Choosing on follower count alone
- Not checking where the audience lives
- Ignoring the creator’s past brand partnerships
- Sending generic mass messages
- Signing a long contract before testing
Key takeaways
- Audience fit beats follower count
- Check genuine engagement
- Compare cost per engaged person
- Test small, then scale
Frequently asked questions
How many influencers should I work with?
For a first campaign, three to ten micro creators gives variety and lets you see who performs.
Should I use an influencer platform?
Platforms speed up search and reporting for larger campaigns. For a few local creators, manual search works well.
What about local Brisbane creators?
For local businesses, a local creator with a few thousand engaged followers in your area can be more valuable than a national name.
Your next step
Find creators who fit your brand
We research, vet and shortlist creators whose audiences match your customers, then manage the partnerships.
Explore influencer marketing