Reduce e-commerce returns without hurting sales
How to reduce e-commerce returns by fixing their causes, without a strict policy that stops shoppers buying.

Returns are a normal part of online shopping, and an easy returns policy is one of the strongest reasons people buy from a store. But each return costs money: two-way shipping, staff time, repackaging and sometimes stock that can’t be resold.
The best way to reduce returns isn’t a stricter policy. It’s making sure customers buy the right thing the first time.
Find out why products come back
Ask for a return reason on every return and track it by product. Most stores find that a small number of products cause a large share of returns, and that one or two reasons dominate.
- Wrong size or fit
- Looks different from the photos
- Quality not as expected
- Arrived damaged
- Changed my mind
- Ordered several to choose from
Fix the cause, not the policy
- Effect on returns
- Effect on sales
Our view, scored out of 5 (higher is better). Fixing information gaps lowers returns and lifts sales; restricting the policy lowers both.
Count what returns really cost
- 2,000
- 18%
- $22
- 10%
- $35
- 4%
- Returns per month
- 360
- Monthly cost of returns
- $9,180
- Annual saving from the reduction
- $24,480
Return rate reduction is in percentage points. This ignores lost profit on refunds, so the true cost is higher.
Make sizing and fit clear
- Show measurements in centimetres, not just S/M/L
- Add fit notes: “runs small, size up”
- Show model height and the size they’re wearing
- Use a fit finder or size recommendation tool for apparel and footwear
- Highlight reviews that mention fit
Encourage exchanges over refunds
An exchange keeps the sale. Make exchanges free and easy, offer instant store credit with a small bonus, and send the replacement before the original arrives back for trusted customers.
Keep the policy generous but clear
A clear, fair returns policy shown on the product page builds confidence. Australian Consumer Law already requires a remedy for faulty or misdescribed products. For change-of-mind returns, a reasonable window and simple process usually win more sales than they cost.
How this looks in your industry
Illustrative examples
Closest to you
E-commerce
A footwear brand
The problem: Most returns were for size.
What changed: Added fit notes, centimetre measurements and a size finder.
Result: Fewer size returns without a stricter policy.
Closest to you
Retail
A homewares store
The problem: Cushions came back for colour differences.
What changed: Shot products in natural light and added colour notes.
Result: Fewer “not as pictured” returns.
Closest to you
E-commerce
A womenswear label
The problem: Refunds outnumbered exchanges.
What changed: Made exchanges free and offered bonus store credit.
Result: More sales kept as exchanges.
Common mistakes
- Tightening the policy before fixing product information
- Not recording return reasons
- Treating all returns the same, rather than by product
- Making exchanges harder than refunds
- Using photos that flatter more than they inform
Key takeaways
- Track return reasons by product
- Fix size, fit and photo issues first
- Push exchanges and store credit
- Keep the policy clear and fair
Frequently asked questions
What’s a normal return rate?
It varies widely. Fashion and footwear tend to see the highest return rates; homewares and electronics are usually much lower.
Should I charge for returns?
Some large retailers do. For smaller brands, free or low-cost exchanges with paid change-of-mind returns can be a fair middle ground.
Do I have to accept change-of-mind returns?
Not under Australian Consumer Law, but many retailers do as a sales advantage. Faulty or misdescribed products must be remedied.
Your next step
Cut returns and keep the sales
We’ll analyse your return reasons, fix the product pages and policies driving them, and track the result.
Explore e-commerce optimisation