Selling on Amazon Australia, eBay or Catch: worth it?
Selling on Amazon Australia, eBay or Catch: the costs, benefits and risks of marketplaces for your brand.

Amazon, eBay and Catch each bring millions of Australian shoppers. Listing there can lift sales quickly, especially for products people search for by name. But you pay for that reach through fees, tougher price competition and less control over the customer experience.
This guide compares the main marketplaces and shows how to check whether they would be profitable for you.
The main Australian marketplaces
- Amazon Australia: largest search-led marketplace; strong for branded and commodity products; Fulfilment by Amazon available
- eBay Australia: broad audience, strong in electronics, auto parts, collectables and value shopping
- Catch: deal-focused marketplace with a younger audience
- Others to consider: Kogan, Bunnings MarketLink (for eligible home and garden brands), MyDeal and Temple & Webster for homewares
Marketplace vs your own store
- Marketplace
- Own store
Our view, scored out of 5 (higher is better for you).
Check the margin per order
Marketplace fees typically combine a referral or commission fee on each sale, plus optional fulfilment, advertising and subscription costs. Run your products through the numbers before listing.
- Sale price: $60
- Product cost: -$20
- Marketplace commission: -$9
- Fulfilment & shipping: -$10
- Marketplace ads: -$6
- Returns allowance: -$2
- What you keep: $13
Illustrative example. Commission and fulfilment rates vary by marketplace and category — check current fee schedules.
Estimate profit across a month
- $60
- $20
- 15%
- $10
- $6
- 300
- Profit per order
- $15
- Margin per order
- 25%
- Monthly profit
- $4,500
Include a returns allowance in your product cost if your category has high returns.
Protect your brand
- Register your trademark and use brand registry tools where available
- Keep pricing consistent so you don’t undercut your own store
- List a curated range rather than everything
- Use marketplace packaging inserts to invite customers to your own store (within each marketplace’s rules)
- Watch for unauthorised resellers
How this looks in your industry
Illustrative examples
Closest to you
E-commerce
A phone accessories brand
The problem: Searches for its products happened mostly on Amazon.
What changed: Listed a curated range on Amazon with brand registry.
Result: Extra sales without discounting the main store.
Closest to you
Retail
A furniture store
The problem: Bulky items had thin marketplace margins.
What changed: Ran the numbers and listed only smaller, higher-margin items.
Result: Avoided loss-making listings.
Closest to you
E-commerce
A clothing brand
The problem: Resellers were undercutting prices.
What changed: Registered the trademark and kept pricing consistent.
Result: Better control of brand and pricing.
Common mistakes
- Listing without calculating margin per order
- Undercutting your own store’s prices
- Listing low-margin, bulky products
- Ignoring marketplace advertising costs
- Not registering your brand before listing
Key takeaways
- Marketplaces trade margin for reach
- Run every product through the fee maths
- List a curated, high-margin range
- Protect your brand and pricing
Frequently asked questions
Which marketplace is best in Australia?
Amazon for search-led products, eBay for broad and value categories, Catch for deals. Many brands start with one and add others.
Should I use Fulfilment by Amazon?
It can improve delivery speed and visibility, but adds fees and storage costs. It suits products that sell steadily.
Will marketplaces hurt my own store?
They can if prices are lower there. Consistent pricing and a curated range reduce the risk.
Your next step
Decide on marketplaces with real numbers
We’ll model marketplace profitability for your range and set up listings that protect your brand and margin.
Explore marketplace strategy